Hands Behind Innovations
I think the primary purpose of technological advancement is to serve humans, to provide convenience and comfort. From the prehistoric periods, humans have started developing and utilizing tools to help improve the quality of life. We sharpened stones into spears for hunting and weaved clothing from animal skins against the cold. This instinct has followed us into modern days. Technology innovations, such as robots in this prompt, are innocuous and can be incredibly progressive. However, ethical concerns sometimes stem from questions of how humans implement technologies.
A couple years ago, I came across a news article reporting on city sanitation workers being forced to wear GPS-tracking smartwatches. Sanitation workers in Nanjing West Bank Environmental Service were required to wear smartwatches that report their activities and location to the company’s control room. If a worker remained in a standstill for longer than 20 minutes, an alarm would go off, prompting a supervisor to go investigate, and wages would be deducted.
In this case of GPS tracking smartwatches, I think it’s a great technology rendered exploitative under human implementation. The companies decided to use it for unethical mass surveillance. Alternatively, these watches can be useful if used for parents to safely keep track of their children’s whereabouts. Instead of making the sanitation workers’ job easier, these smartwatches placed disproportionate power in the hands of the company, the controllers. They are making people already out of power more confined, pressured, and penalized. In addition, these smartwatches were experimented on people traditionally viewed as lower-paid and less protected in society, leaving them vulnerable to challenge in these oppressive systems. Smartwatches aren’t necessarily equivalent to robots, but I believe they raise the same concern.
Returning to the prompt on the ethicality of robot use in the job market, I don’t think any jobs should be turned completely lead by robots or artificial intelligence. We have jobs emerging in society because we have a human-oriented demand, which deserves to be treated humanely. However, this is not to say we shouldn’t implement robots in the job market. I think their tasks should be limited to serving humans solving the problems. In the case of sanitation workers, instead of developing smartwatches aimed to squeeze every last bit of productivity out of them, technology developments should be aimed to ease their labors, perhaps introducing robots that clear leaves or handle other physically demanding tasks. The idea is also similar to why we oppose writing with artificial intelligence. If a human is reading some work to gain knowledge, they deserve to read the wisdom of another human instead of an empty imitation.
Works Cited:
"'Work Harder! Work Harder!': Backlash over Chinese Street Workers Forced to Wear Monitoring Devices." ABC News, https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-04-17/chinese-companies-using-smartwatches-to-track-workers:-report/10985890. Accessed 27 September 2026.
--------------------
Thank you for reading!
Toodles!
Hi Ruijing! I've never heard about the GPS smartwatches, but wow that's scary! As you point out, technology can disproportionately benefit the powerful and widen existing inequalities. How do you think we should ensure that technology is used in an equitable and fair way? How do we make sure that technology doesn't continue to exploit people or render people unemployable? I know there have been swirlings of an AI moratorium around the world, but would that solve the problem? I'm curious to hear your thoughts on this! Thanks for sharing!
ReplyDeleteHello Ruijing! The GPS watch story is super intriguing, I had no idea that was going on. It is more interesting that the company believed this was the best way to keep their employees in check, even if doing so was unethical. I agree that robots should only be used hand in hand with humans to aid in solving problems, instead of relying on AI entirely. I like how you provided an alternative use for the GPS watches, I agree that parents would benefit from the watches because children need constant surveillance. Great post!
ReplyDeleteHey Ruijing! I loved your blog and how you brought attention to a story that wasn't well-known. I completely agree that instead of robots eplacing "undesirable" jobs, robots in the job market should only be used to make workers lives easier. This is because there's people that rely on jobs like sanitation work that have poor conditions and instead of being aided by robotic development they find their jobs threatened. I also really liked your spin on the GPS watches and how they could be used to help worried parents opposed to greedy company owners. Great job!
ReplyDelete